The True Vine
The Deep Waters Way | Series: I AM | Episode 27: The True Vine
In this seventh and final installment of our series on the predicate I AM statements in the Gospel of John, we examine Jesus' declaration on the way to Gethsemane: "I am the true vine, and my Father is the vinedresser" (John 15:1). Departing the Upper Room at the conclusion of John 14, Jesus and His disciples descended into the Kidron Valley, passing active terraced vineyards on the slopes of Jerusalem. Just as the massive temple lights during Sukkot anchored His claim as the Light of the World, these tangible vines provided a living sermon illustrating His identity as alēthinos—the true, genuine reality behind Old Testament symbols of Israel as God's vine (Isaiah 5, Jeremiah 2, Hosea 10). Concluding our participation framework (alongside The Resurrection and the Life and The Way, the Truth, and the Life), this episode contrasts judicial removal (airo) with relational pruning (kathairo), explores abiding (menō) as continuous faith ("faithing"), and shows how being grafted into Christ produces moral transformation, holiness, and full joy for the glory of the Father.
Core Takeaways
- The Culmination of Participation: Following Resurrection (John 11) and The Way (John 14), I am the True Vine (John 15:1–11) concludes the participation framework and the overall I AM series, demonstrating that believers are not distant observers of a Savior, but branches dynamically united to Christ as their living rootstock.
- Jesus as the True Vine (Alēthinos): Contrasting Old Testament passages where Israel was depicted as a choice vine that became wild and degenerate (Isaiah 5, Jeremiah 2, Hosea 10), Jesus reveals that Israel was merely a symbol pointing to Him. He is the true, genuine rootstock (alēthinos) into which both Jews and Gentiles must be grafted by grace.
- Judicial Removal vs. Relational Pruning (John 15:2): Exegeting the Greek terminology, host Ray contrasts airo (the judicial removal of fruitless, external attachments like Judas) with kathairo (the relational pruning and cleansing of healthy, fruit-bearing branches), refuting misunderstandings that soften judicial removal into mere dirt-cleansing.
- Abiding as Continuous Faith (Menō): Because English lacks a continuous verb for faith, abiding (menō) functions as "faithing"—keeping house in Christ, remaining in His presence, and surrendering self-reliance so His life-giving sap flows unimpeded through the branches.
- Fruit as Moral Transformation and Holiness: True spiritual fruit is not merely external works or spiritual achievements (which even Judas performed), but moral character aligned with God—holiness, the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22–23), and experiencing Christ's full joy to bring ultimate glory to the Father.
Depth of Insight
- Living Sermon in the Kidron Valley: As Jesus and the 11 walked out of Jerusalem on the night of His betrayal toward Gethsemane (John 14:31), the active terraced vineyards along the Kidron Valley provided the visual anchor for Jesus' living sermon on the True Vine and the Vinedresser.
- The Sovereign Work of the Vinedresser: A branch cannot graft itself onto a vine through moral effort. Grafting is an act of sovereign grace executed entirely by the Father (Romans 11), meaning fruitfulness is the natural result of attachment, never the purchase price to earn it.
- The Sculptor's Chisel (Kathairo): Illustrating relational pruning, the episode connects kathairo (pruning/cleansing) to Michelangelo's famous sculpting philosophy—chipping away everything that doesn't look like the subject—and theSkitsGuys' video God's Chisel. Pruning may be painful, but it is active care, not punishment.
- Divine Desire to Dwell with Humanity: Abiding in Christ fulfills God's long-standing covenantal intention—traced from the Garden of Eden and Abraham to Moses and the Tabernacle in Exodus—to dwell continuously among His people through the Messiah.
- The Farmer and the Prize Pumpkin: Like a farmer receiving accolades at the fair for a prize pumpkin, the Father (the Vinedresser) receives all the glory when believers bear much fruit. The branch receives no self-exaltation, only full, abiding joy.
Featured Scripture
- John 15:1–5: "I am the true vine, and my Father is the vinedresser. Every branch in me that does not bear fruit he takes away, and every branch that does bear fruit he prunes, that it may bear more fruit. Already you are clean because of the word that I have spoken to you. Abide in me, and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit by itself, unless it abides in the vine, neither can you, unless you abide in me. I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing."
- John 15:8–11: "By this my Father is glorified, that you bear much fruit and so prove to be my disciples. As the Father has loved me, so have I loved you. Abide in my love. If you keep my commandments, you will abide in my love, just as I have kept my Father's commandments and abide in his love. These things I have spoken to you, that my joy may be in you, and that your joy may be full."
Theological Connections
- Isaiah 5:1–7: The Song of the Unfruitful Vineyard, where Israel is depicted as God's planted vine that produced wild, useless grapes.
- Jeremiah 2:21 & Hosea 10:1: Prophetic imagery of Israel as a choice vine turned degenerate and wild.
- Romans 11:17–24: Paul's olive tree metaphor of wild Gentile branches being grafted by grace into the rootstock of God's covenant.
- Galatians 5:22–23: The fruit of the Spirit (love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, self-control) as the definition of moral transformation.
- Ephesians 2:8–10: Salvation by grace through faith resulting in good works prepared beforehand by God.
Scholarly Context & Commentary
- Bruce Wilkinson: Secrets of the Vine. (Discussed regarding the interpretation of airo as lifting up vs. judicial removal).
- Joseph Henry Thayer: Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament. (On the lexical connotations of airo for taking up, removal, and destruction vs. kathairo for pruning).
- Michelangelo Buonarroti: Sculptural principle of chipping away marble to reveal the form within (illustrating divine pruning).
- The Skit Guys: God's Chisel. (Dramatization of God's loving, transformational pruning process).
- Albert Barnes & Adam Clarke: Commentary insights on biblical vine imagery and Old Testament shadows.
- The Holy Bible: English Standard Version. Wheaton, IL: Crossway Bibles, 2016.
Support The Deep Waters Way
Producing The Deep Waters Way is a labor of love, but it does carry real administrative and operational costs. If the show has been a blessing to your walk with Christ, would you pray about helping us cover those costs? You can make a contribution directly through our secure online page. Your support is deeply appreciated and allows us to keep slipping the moorings and heading for the deep waters.
Support the Show: www.thedeepwatersway.com/support
Transcript
[COLD OPEN] Holiness and Moral Character
Isaiah 5 tells us fruit is moral character in keeping with God's character. It is becoming like Christ. In other words, holiness.
[Theme Music Intro]
The deep waters way. Where scripture, theology, and transformation meet.
Introduction: Setting the Scene Outside Jerusalem
Last week, we looked at John chapter 14 and Jesus statement that he is the way, the truth, and the life. At the end of chapter 14, Jesus tells the disciples, "Rise, let us go from here." And so, they get up and they leave the upper room. Now, we don't know exactly where the upper room is. Tradition places it on the west side of Jerusalem. And we know that they're headed to Gethsemane, which is on the Mount of Olives, east of Jerusalem, across the Kidron Valley. So, we have the disciples and Jesus walking out into the night across the city of Jerusalem and descending into the Kidron Valley. As they do this, they would have passed numerous vineyards outside the city walls.
As they descended down into the Kidron Valley and crossed the brook and headed back up the slopes of the Mount of Olives toward Gethsemane. And just like what we talked about a few weeks ago with the statement, I am the light, just like the massive temple lights left from the festival of Sukkot would have anchored that statement of Jesus that he is the light of the world. Walking past these active terrace vineyards on the slopes of Jerusalem anchors his statement that he is the true vine. It's easy to imagine Jesus pointing to the landscape, pointing to the vines, maybe even reaching out and touching one and lifting it up and turning that then into a living sermon. One of the things you have to understand as far as context is that in the Old Testament, Israel was referred to as God's vine numerous times. Isaiah 5:1-7, Jeremiah 2:21, Hosea 10:1 among others all refer to Israel as God's vine.
They use the idea, they use the terms luxuriant vine, choice vine, and they describe God picking Israel, transplanting the nation to a vineyard, cultivating and caring for it. But these very same passages also tell us Israel was a degenerate wild vine that failed to produce true fruit. Isaiah uses a word that is literally translated wild grapes and the idea is worthless and foul tasting, maybe even foul smelling and in other words something useless. The revelation here is that Israel was never the rootstock. Yes, Israel's described as a vine, but Israel is not the vine. Israel's being used here as a symbol of what is to come. And the reality behind that symbol then is Jesus. And as Paul would tell us, everyone, whether Jew or Gentile, must be grafted into Christ. We aren't observing a savior from a distance. We're united to him as branches are united to the trunk on which they grow.
Today, we're wrapping up both the participation category of our series and the I am series itself by looking at John 15:1-11 and Jesus statement that he is the true vine. Before we get into that though, I'm Ray and this is the deep waters way. Thank you so much for joining me in this ongoing journey into the depths of faith. It's my hope that through this podcast you are encouraged and enabled to grow closer to God and have a better understanding of scripture and God's will for your life. Last week, I told you that I'm in the process of putting together both a guide to help you in how you study the Bible as well as a newsletter to be made available to listeners of the podcast. Those things are still in the works, but I'm currently planning on making them available on November 10th.
That being said, if you've not already done so, you definitely want to subscribe or follow wherever you listen to this podcast so that you don't miss out on the details of how to get that guide, the newsletter, or for that matter any episode. Now, grab a cup of coffee or hot tea and settle in. It's time to slip the moorings and head for the deep waters.
Part I: The True Vine and the Vinedresser (John 15:1)
In verse one of John 15, Jesus says, "I am the true vine, and my father is the vine dresser." Now, again, it's easy to see Jesus making this statement as he and the disciples descend out of Jerusalem past these vineyards and he points to one of these vines that's growing there and says, "You see the vine? Well, I'm the true vine." And he describes the father as the vine dresser. In verses two and following, then he talks about branches that are attached to the vine. He talks about abiding in him. He talks about producing fruit and we're going to get into all of that and look at what Jesus is trying to convey here.
But before we do, let's look just at this first verse for a moment. And this idea of the vine and the vine dresser and then moving into verse two, the branches. Jesus says, "I am the true vine." In other words, he is the absolute source of life. He is the root. He is the source of vitality for all that takes place. And he uses this word true. And it's real easy for us to read true and think, oh, true versus false. In other words, Jesus is the true vine in contrast to a counterfeit vine or a false vine. That's not what the word true here is doing. The idea that's really being conveyed here is the comparison between real or genuine to the symbol which came before. Like I mentioned a moment ago, Israel is referred to in the Old Testament as a vine. That's symbology which points to Jesus. And Jesus is here saying, "You know that symbol? Well, I'm the reality behind that symbol." And he calls the father the vine dresser.
In other words, the father is the sovereign active caretaker who manages and tends and oversees the vineyard. He's the one who chose Israel and placed it in the vineyard. And he is the one who grafts new branches into the vine. The one who prunes and the one who removes unfruitful branches. Now throughout the Old Testament, God is often referred to as a vine dresser, as a one who cares for a vineyard. So this is not a new idea that Jesus is drawing on. He's actually drawing on concepts and ideas that the apostles would have been familiar with. But then he begins to talk about branches. And branches when talking about a vine are completely dependent upon the vine, upon the trunk, the rootstock. A branch has no life apart from the stock. And without a viable real connection to the vine and its lifegiving sap, a branch can't produce fruit no matter how good it looks.
But it's only going to look good for so long because if there's no connection, then ultimately it withers and dies and is removed by the father because it doesn't belong and it only appears to be connected.
Part II: Judicial Removal vs. Relational Pruning (John 15:2–3)
And then in verses 2 and 3, Jesus says, "Every branch in me that does not bear fruit, he takes away. And every branch that does bear fruit, he prunes that it may bear more fruit. Already you are clean because of the word I have spoken to you." Now, there's several different things going on here, but one of the things that I want to point out involves the language that's being used here. There's three words that are used that are related in their construction and their etymology, yet they have somewhat different meanings. The first is airo or iro, and it means lifting up or taking away. And there's been some effort in the past to soften what the passage is actually saying.
For instance, in Bruce Wilkinson's Secrets of the Vine, he claims that iro here means lifting up drooping branches out of the dirt. In other words, they've drooped down and they're covered in dirt. And when Jesus says the father removes any branch that does not bear fruit, what Wilkinson and some others have said is that this word takes away actually just means to lift up out of the dirt and clean it off so that it can bear fruit. The problem is that's not what's described or not what seems to be described and the context of the whole passage seems to say otherwise from what is being claimed here. If we look at just the meanings of the words, it is very easy to think, well, that could be what it means because they simply list out a couple of different words or possible meanings or ways that it's used through scripture. And sure enough, lift up is a legitimate translation for iro.
But you can't just look at what the lexicon says, oh, this is a possible meaning for this word, and say, well, that must be what it means here. You have to look at the fuller context of the passage. And to that end, some lexicons like Thayer, for instance, give us a little more context, a little more of the connotations behind the word. Thayer actually says that the idea of taking up here is more along the lines of taking up into your hands, picking up or carrying off. And he includes then the connotation for destruction or for removal. In other words, getting rid of, getting out of the way. And this is in contrast then to the word that's translated pruning, kathairo. And yes, there's the same root there with a prefix added. But the idea behind kathairo is pruning and cleansing, in other words, what some would argue iro itself means. But again, the context doesn't seem to be bearing that out. I think what's being described here is two separate operations.
The first is a judicial removal. That is, Jesus says in the first half of verse two, "Every branch in me that does not bear fruit, he takes away." This is the cutting away of dead, fruitless, external attachments. And one of the easiest ways I've found to begin to understand this goes back to when Jesus talks about disciples coming to him and saying, "Lord, didn't we do all of these things in your name?" And he says, "I never knew you." In other words, there was no connection. And because there was no connection, there was no fruit. And we'll talk about the meaning of fruit in a little bit. But just to give you a preview of where we're going to head with that, fruit is not necessarily works. And one of the things I think as well here is that this points directly to Judas, who just hours earlier had left the room to go and betray Jesus. The second operation that's going on here is relational pruning. And this is that word kathairo.
In the second half of verse two, Jesus says, "Every branch that does bear fruit, he prunes that it may bear more fruit." In other words, the idea here is that he's trimming healthy shoots. He's trimming them back so that they're able to grow and bear more fruit. Pruning is active care. And even though it can sometimes be painful, it's not punishment. Sometimes God allows things into our lives that cause pain or sometimes he uses the consequences of our choices and he does these things in order to draw us closer to him. It's the same idea that's expressed in the statement that has been attributed to various individuals including Michelangelo that in order to create a sculpture you simply take a block of marble and chip away everything that doesn't look like your subject. The same idea actually even made it into a skit by The Skit Guys called God's Chisel. And if you've never seen that skit, if you've never seen that video, I encourage you to look it up on YouTube. After you finish this episode, of course.
Now, I said that the context itself seems to betray the idea that iro and kathairo can be used interchangeably here, that they both can be used to basically mean the act of pruning and caring for and cleaning. In verse three, Jesus tells the 11, "Already you are clean because of the word I have spoken to you." The word translated clean there is katharos and it shares a root with kathairo. Kathairo means to prune. Katharos means to clean. It's the word that we get cathartic from. And so what Jesus is talking about here is that they have already been pruned so that they can bear fruit and that they are then bearing fruit. And again pointing to Judas, he has been removed because he's not bearing fruit. Even though he appears to have connection, there's no fruit. So there's no connection. The 11 on the other hand and disciples in general face the vine dresser's shears for the purpose of growth, not the axe for the purpose of removal.
Now earlier I mentioned that the reality is all of us—Jew, Gentile, it doesn't matter—everyone in order to find life in Christ has to be grafted into him. And this is language that Paul uses in several of his letters, this idea of being grafted in. What you have to understand is a branch doesn't graft itself into the vine. Therefore, you and I don't graft ourselves into Christ through moral effort. That's the work of the vine dresser. He's the one who takes the new branch that he wants to graft into the vine, makes the cut in the vine, places the branch into it, binds up the area, and allows it to heal and grow together. And in so doing, then the lifegiving sap from the vine flows into the branch. That means that the attachment is an act of sovereign grace. It's something done to us. That also means that fruit bearing comes after attachment. A branch left on its own can't bear fruit. It has to be part of the vine. And bearing fruit then is the natural result of being grafted in. You never earn attachment by producing fruit. You produce fruit because you've been attached by grace.
Paul in Romans 11 talking about Gentiles talks about wild olive shoots being grafted into a rootstock. And in fact, I think Romans 11 is a really good place to go back to what I was talking about earlier with iro and kathairo because Paul actually talks about branches being broken off of the vine and new branches being grafted in. That's the very idea then that Jesus is talking about: branches that aren't bearing fruit being broken off, cut away, taken away, and new branches being grafted into their place. The encouragement here is that our security is in the root, not in our own strength. The branch gains strength from the vine, not the other way around.
Part III: Abiding and Continuous Faith (John 15:4–8)
So, what happens when we're grafted in? Well, in verses 4-8, Jesus says this: "Abide in me and I in you. As the branch cannot bear fruit by itself unless it abides in the vine, neither can you, unless you abide in me. I am the vine, you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit. For apart from me, you can do nothing. If anyone does not abide in me, he is thrown away like a branch and withers. And the branches are gathered, thrown into the fire, and burned. If you abide in me and my words abide in you, ask whatever you wish and it will be done for you. By this my father is glorified that you bear much fruit and so prove to be my disciples." Now that word abiding is something that we don't use very often even though this is coming from a modern translation. Abiding is just not a word that we hear very much. So what do we mean by that? Well, abiding simply means to live with. It's where you dwell.
And that's part of the idea of what Jesus is talking about here: live in me and I in you. But that still doesn't help clear up what it means in this context. Oftentimes, and rightly so, we think of belief and faith as roughly the same thing. And yes, they are. The problem comes in though when we don't have a proper definition of belief and faith. We often treat belief as simply a static thing—it's merely agreement with a set of facts. And honestly, we tend to treat faith the same way as well. We tell people, "Oh, have faith," and we simply mean just believe, just agree, this is what's going to happen. Trust that this is what's going to happen. And we simply mean it from the standpoint of think that this is what's going to take place. But biblically, belief and faith, faith and trust are not static words. They are active verbs. To believe, to have faith, to trust biblically means to act as though what you say is true is indeed true.
Part of the problem is the word believe has shifted in its meaning a little bit over the years and English doesn't have a continuous verb for faith. We don't say "I'm faithing that this will happen." Although with our modern tendency to turn various nouns into verbs by adding -ing to them—for instance, adulting, mathing—we could easily just start using "faithing" as a word. Maybe we ought to try to make that a trend. But the idea here is that Jesus is using abiding as this continuous verb form for faith. To abide is to live continuously in the presence and the strength of God, trusting wholeheartedly in him. Jesus is saying essentially, keep house in me. Stay put in me. Build your life in me. And this is the idea that goes all the way back. We could say Exodus, but really it goes back even further than that because it goes all the way back to the garden where God walked with Adam in the cool of the evening. And then as we come forward, we see him communicating with Abraham. We see him working through Joseph. We see him with Moses in the wilderness with Israel and saying, "I want to dwell in your presence." And all of these things are foreshadowing. They're precursors to what he wants to do. And this is something the prophets make very clear that all of these things that we see in Israel's history that God has said, "I want to do with you, my people," He's going to make a reality through the Messiah. And so when Jesus says, "I am the vine. Abide in me so that you can bear fruit," this is exactly what he's talking about. And part of the idea that's being expressed here is that abiding means you give up your self-reliance. You see, a branch doesn't work to pull water from a vine. It just happens. And so when we abide in him, we let his life flow into and through us. It's resting, trusting, and choosing to remain in him. And the goal then is that we bear fruit and experience full joy.
Part IV: Fruitfulness, Character, and Full Joy (John 15:9–11)
Verses 9-11, Jesus says, "As the father has loved me, so have I loved you. Abide in my love. If you keep my commandments, you will abide in my love, just as I have kept my father's commandments and abide in his love. These things I have spoken to you that my joy may be in you and that your joy may be full." The progression here is that by abiding in him, we bear fruit. And as we abide in him and bear fruit, the father, the vine dresser, prunes us, cleans us, lifts us up so that we bear more fruit. And as we bear more fruit, he continues to prune us and clean us and make us look more like Jesus so that we bear much fruit. We might ask, what is fruit? And I think we get back again to that idea: Lord, Lord, didn't we prophesy in your name? Didn't we preach in your name? Didn't we cast out demons in your name? Didn't we do all of these things? And Jesus says, "Depart from me. I never knew you." In other words, without connection to him, the works mean nothing. Can fruit mean works?
Absolutely. In Ephesians 2, where Paul tells us that we're saved by grace through faith and not of ourselves, not by works, he goes on to tell us that we're saved in order to do works. That's part of the fruit. But Judas did works. But Judas had no connection. And so fruit has to be more than works. And based upon what the prophets and specifically Isaiah 5 tells us, fruit is moral character in keeping with God's character. It is becoming like Christ. In other words, holiness. And then Paul in Galatians tells us about the fruit of the spirit that should be being produced in us: love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. And Jesus says, "You will be known by your fruit," by the transformation of your character and of the way of life. Because you look different in him. You act different in him. You are different in him. And so, yes, there's works that are fruit, but there's also a change in moral character. And without that change, without that transformation of being, works are meaningless. And that transformation only comes from being grafted into him, finding our life in him, abiding in him. And if we want to use that word that we talked about coining a while ago, "faithing" in him, living differently because of what we believe about who he is and what he has done and what he is doing in us. And he tells us the purpose: to glorify the father. He says, "My father is glorified when you bear fruit. When you start to look like Jesus, you bring glory to the father. When you obey Jesus' commands, you bring glory to the father. And as you do that—and this is one of the things that we need to understand and Jesus said this—he says, "My yoke is light. What I give to you is not burdensome." When we obey Jesus, when we obey God's commands, it's not a burden to us. It's not something we do out of slavish obligation or a transactional kind of relationship.
It's something we do because he's making us different. And as we do those things, we begin to experience joy in a new way. He says, "That my joy may be in you." Jesus takes delight in doing the will of the father. And that joy is in us when we're connected to him. And because that joy is in us, our joy is made full. And notice who gets the glory in all of this. It's the father, the vine dresser. Just like a farmer taking a prize pumpkin to the fair, he's the one who receives the accolades, not the pumpkin. We don't get glory from living this life. God does. The father does through the life of the son being made real in us and the fruit of the spirit being produced in us. This is life in Christ to bring glory to the father and experience his joy in us.
Conclusion & Sign-off
So, think about your life. Are you connected to Christ? Have you been grafted into him? Because if you can't answer that question with a yes, nothing else matters. If your answer is no, then let me encourage you. Trust in him. Surrender to him. Let the father graft you into Christ that you may have life. But if your answer is yes, that you are indeed grafted into Christ, then let me ask you this: where are you trying to manufacture fruit on your own instead of simply abiding in the vine? And along with that, can you trust the vine dresser's pruning in this season as care rather than condemnation? Thank you for joining me today. I hope that you found this episode encouraging or enlightening. If you did, would you share it with a friend or relative or co-worker? Doing so is the best way to help this show grow and to reach new people. Now, go into the world, do the work of God, be the people of God. It's time to slip the moorings and head for the deep waters.
The deep waters way. Where scripture, theology, and transformation meet.
